"Cherry Wine" is a love song that delves into the challenging aspects of affection, specifically portraying a relationship marked by abuse. Written from the perspective of a man, the lyrics explore how love can endure through abusive episodes and the societal contexts that enable them. It's described as concluding Hozier's debut album on an intimate and apologetic note, with the singer seeking redemption. The song's folk and indie folk sound, with its resonant acoustic guitars and Hozier's vocals, creates a stark contrast to the difficult themes it addresses. Playing this song means channeling the complex emotions of enduring love amidst pain and the quiet struggle for understanding.